Mike and Melissa moved in together four years ago when they bought their house in Tallahassee, Florida. At the time, there was plenty of room for the couple and Mike’s two kids. But Melissa’s passion for collecting vintage items has gotten out of control. With Mike’s twins about to leave for college, Melissa has her eyes set on taking over their rooms too for her collectibles, and Mike isn’t pleased. Their 1,800-square-foot home just doesn’t have enough organized storage to contain Melissa’s collection, and Mike fears the kids won’t feel welcome if she takes over their rooms. Mike wants to renovate. Melissa thinks they’ve outgrown the home and need a fresh start. Now they must decide if they want to move or improve.