Joan and her boyfriend Tony are seeing apparitions and hearing hushed conversations in their New Jersey home. Both are concerned that the spirits are influencing their behavior: a non-drinker, Tony has turned to the bottle while Joan has thoughts of harming herself. PRS uncovers deaths inside the home with eerie connections to their alleged haunting, while Ryan considers the possibility that Tony is possessed. Psychic and demonologist Lorraine Warren joins PRS on the case.